AVOIDING Common mistakes when remodeling an older home

Tutor style home

Remodeling an older home can be one of the most rewarding projects a homeowner takes on. With charm, character, and craftsmanship that newer homes often lack, older houses in Hermitage, Sharon, Greenville, and surrounding Western Pennsylvania communities offer a strong foundation for creating your dream living space. However, working with older homes also comes with unique challenges that require experience, planning, and attention to detail. At McElhinny Brothers Construction Company, with over 60 years of trusted service, we’ve seen the most common mistakes homeowners make when remodeling older homes—and more importantly, how to avoid them.

1. Ignoring the Structural Integrity

One of the biggest mistakes is focusing only on cosmetic upgrades without addressing the home’s underlying structure. Issues like outdated wiring, old plumbing, or a weakened foundation must be carefully evaluated before you invest in new finishes. Overlooking these critical areas can lead to costly repairs down the road.

Our advice: Always start with a thorough inspection to ensure your remodel has a solid foundation—literally and figuratively.

2. Underestimating the Budget

Older homes often hide surprises behind walls and under floors. Homeowners sometimes underestimate how much to set aside for unexpected repairs.

Our advice: Build in a contingency fund—typically 10–20% of your budget—for those “surprise” issues. With decades of experience, our team helps clients prepare realistic budgets from the start.

3. Losing the Home’s Character

One of the joys of remodeling an older home is preserving the craftsmanship that makes it unique. Sometimes, in the rush to modernize, homeowners replace historic trim, woodwork, or original layouts with cookie-cutter designs.

Our advice: Work with a contractor who respects the home’s history while updating it for modern living. We pride ourselves on balancing timeless character with modern convenience.

4. Skipping Energy Efficiency Upgrades

Older homes weren’t built with today’s energy standards in mind. Drafty windows, lack of insulation, and inefficient heating systems can quickly add to your monthly bills.

Our advice: Consider energy-efficient windows, insulation upgrades, and HVAC improvements during your remodel. These investments pay off in both comfort and long-term savings.

5. DIYing Complex Work

While many homeowners are handy, older homes come with quirks that require professional expertise. Mistakes with plumbing, electrical systems, or structural changes can put your family’s safety at risk.

Our advice: Leave the complex work to experienced, licensed contractors who know how to handle the unexpected. At McElhinny Brothers, we’ve been navigating the unique challenges of older homes in our community fOR OVER 60 YEARS,

Trust Experience for Your Remodel

Remodeling an older home is more than just updating—it’s about honoring the home’s history while creating a safe, functional, and beautiful space for today. With over 60 years of experience serving families across Hermitage, Sharon, Greenville, Grove City, and beyond, McElhinny Brothers Construction Company is here to help you avoid common mistakes and achieve lasting results. CALL US TODAY FOR YOUR NEXT PROJECT OR UPGRADE AT (724) 588-8181.